Benchmark Report [Results .csv]

Configuration

Length of signals: 256

Repetitions: 2000

SNRin values: -5, 0, 5, 10,

Methods

  • monte_carlo_test

  • global_mad_test

  • global_rank_env_test

  • APF

Signals

  • LinearChirp

Mean results tables:

The results shown here are the average and 95% Clopper-Pearson CI of the estimated detection power with Bonferroni correction. Best performances are bolded.

Signal: LinearChirp [View Plot] [Get .csv]

Method + Param

SNRin=-5dB (average)

SNRin=-5dB (CI)

SNRin=0dB (average)

SNRin=0dB (CI)

SNRin=5dB (average)

SNRin=5dB (CI)

SNRin=10dB (average)

SNRin=10dB (CI)

0

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 0.5, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.05

[‘0.03’, ‘0.06’]

0.07

[‘0.06’, ‘0.09’]

0.14

[‘0.12’, ‘0.17’]

0.29

[‘0.26’, ‘0.32’]

1

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs_vs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 0.5, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.04

[‘0.03’, ‘0.06’]

0.07

[‘0.05’, ‘0.09’]

0.14

[‘0.12’, ‘0.16’]

0.28

[‘0.25’, ‘0.31’]

2

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 1.0, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.06

[‘0.04’, ‘0.07’]

0.17

[‘0.14’, ‘0.19’]

0.65

[‘0.61’, ‘0.68’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

3

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs_vs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 1.0, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.07

[‘0.06’, ‘0.09’]

0.27

[‘0.24’, ‘0.30’]

0.94

[‘0.92’, ‘0.95’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

4

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 2.0, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.06

[‘0.05’, ‘0.08’]

0.17

[‘0.15’, ‘0.20’]

0.65

[‘0.62’, ‘0.68’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

5

monte_carlo_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs_vs’, ‘pnorm’: 2, ‘rmax’: 2.0, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.07

[‘0.06’, ‘0.09’]

0.27

[‘0.25’, ‘0.30’]

0.94

[‘0.92’, ‘0.95’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

6

global_mad_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs’, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.06

[‘0.04’, ‘0.07’]

0.16

[‘0.14’, ‘0.18’]

0.65

[‘0.61’, ‘0.68’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

7

global_mad_test{‘statistic’: ‘Frs_vs’, ‘MC_reps’: 2499}

0.07

[‘0.05’, ‘0.08’]

0.27

[‘0.24’, ‘0.30’]

0.96

[‘0.95’, ‘0.97’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

8

global_rank_env_test{‘fun’: ‘Fest’, ‘correction’: ‘rs’}

0.07

[‘0.05’, ‘0.08’]

0.20

[‘0.17’, ‘0.22’]

0.91

[‘0.89’, ‘0.93’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

9

global_rank_env_test{‘fun’: ‘Fest’, ‘correction’: ‘rs’, ‘rmin’: 0.65, ‘rmax’: 1.05}

0.09

[‘0.07’, ‘0.11’]

0.34

[‘0.31’, ‘0.37’]

0.97

[‘0.96’, ‘0.98’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

10

global_rank_env_test{‘fun’: ‘Fest’, ‘correction’: ‘rs’, ‘transform’: ‘asin(sqrt(.))’}

0.06

[‘0.05’, ‘0.08’]

0.20

[‘0.18’, ‘0.23’]

0.91

[‘0.88’, ‘0.92’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

11

global_rank_env_test{‘fun’: ‘Fest’, ‘correction’: ‘rs’, ‘rmin’: 0.65, ‘rmax’: 1.05, ‘transform’: ‘asin(sqrt(.))’}

0.09

[‘0.07’, ‘0.11’]

0.34

[‘0.31’, ‘0.37’]

0.97

[‘0.96’, ‘0.98’]

1.00

[‘1.00’, ‘1.00’]

12

APF

0.07

[‘0.06’, ‘0.09’]

0.19

[‘0.16’, ‘0.21’]

0.48

[‘0.45’, ‘0.52’]

0.73

[‘0.70’, ‘0.76’]